04 Mar
Westminster Hall
Palestinian Rights: Government Support

The Westminster Hall session on 'Palestinian Rights: Government Support', chaired by Sir John Hayes, saw a comprehensive discussion focused on the challenges faced by Palestinians, the humanitarian crisis in Gaza, and the broader geopolitical implications of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The debate was informed by recent visits to the region by MPs, providing firsthand accounts of the tensions and violence.

Sir Edward Leigh set the stage for the debate by sharing his recent experience in Israel and the west bank, highlighting the dire conditions and the contradictions within and between communities striving for peace across divided lines. His call was centered around ending the occupation of 5 million Palestinians, emphasizing a two-state solution as the only feasible pathway to lasting peace.

Other speakers echoed similar sentiments with concerns ranging from settler violence in the west bank, the humanitarian situation in Gaza, and the Israeli government's settlement policies. There was consensus on condemning the actions of Hamas while also recognizing the disproportionate impact on civilians, particularly women and children.

The discussion brought to light the imbalance in resource access, highlighting UN statistics of around 1,800 settler violence incidents and a stark blockade hindering aid delivery during critical periods.

Paul Waugh and Pippa Heylings recounted personal encounters with locals who are victimized by aggression from both sides. Accounts focused on the destruction of infrastructure crucial for Palestinian livelihoods.

The lack of political progress towards a two-state solution was lamented by many MPs, urging for recognition of Palestinian statehood and better humanitarian coordination between Israel and international actors.

Outcome: The session concluded with a general consensus on the urgent need for a long-term ceasefire, humanitarian assistance, and security framework negotiations. There were calls for diplomatic efforts to facilitate a pathway to peace, with multiple MPs urging the UK to take a stronger stand on Palestinian rights and wider geopolitical implications.

1800 incidents

Settler violence incidents in the West Bank between October 2023 and December 2024 as per UN data.

Statistics:

  • 1,800 incidents of settler violence from data spanning late 2023 up to end of 2024.
  • £129 million commitment from the UK for Palestinian territories, including £41 million through UNRWA for essential services.
  • 38 hostages released in the initial phase of the ceasefire.
£129 million

Funds committed by the UK for essential services and humanitarian aid in Palestinian Territories via UNRWA.

Key Speaker Contributions:

38 hostages

Released during the initial ceasefire deal brokered in the conflict.

Outcome

Debate emphasized strategic diplomatic intervention and international cooperation to revive hopes for a two-state solution while addressing the immediate humanitarian and political challenges.

Key Contributions

Sir Edward LeighChair of the Motion
Conservative

Condemned Hamas unequivocally while advocating for the rights of Palestinians.

Paul WaughLabour MP
Labour

Referred to the suffering viewed on a recent visit, detailing impacts on civilians amid the conflict.

Pippa HeylingsLiberal Democrats MP
Liberal Democrats

Spoke about harm to Palestinians through settler violence.

Richard BurgonLabour MP
Labour

Criticized Israeli settlement policies, comparing it to illegal acts of war.

Jeremy CorbynIndependent MP
Ind

Highlighted international efforts, including ICJ proceedings on occupation legality.

Uma KumaranLabour MP
Labour

Described field visit insights, focusing on IDF and settler-related intimidation.

Shockat AdamIndependent MP
Ind

Denounced Israeli ministers' incendiary rhetoric and policies towards Palestinians.

Tracy GilbertLabour MP
Labour

Recapitulated experiences from the delegation visit, witnessing settler provocations.

Melanie WardLabour MP
Labour

Seconded the points about the indignities Palestinians face under military occupation.

Jim ShannonDUP MP
DUP

While endorsing Israel’s self-defense, emphasized need for compassion towards Palestinian suffering.

Jas AthwalLabour MP
Labour

Advocated for retaining hopes for a two-state solution amidst prevailing conflict challenges.

Martin VickersConservative MP
Conservative

Reflected on past visits highlighting evolving regional conditions.

Sam RushworthLabour MP
Labour

Detailed the UN ICJ’s stance on occupation legitimacy.

Iqbal MohamedIndependent MP
Ind

Described substantial human rights needs unmet by current support systems.

Nadia WhittomeLabour MP
Labour

Linked governmental arms policies to ongoing aggression in Gaza and west bank.

Mr Will ForsterLiberal Democrats MP
Liberal Democrats

Shared experiences from visits emphasizing humanitarian and political dichotomies.

Harpreet UppalLabour MP
Labour

Described healthcare inadequacies attributed to policy and funding barriers.

Monica HardingLiberal Democrats MP
Liberal Democrats

Called for a coherent British stance opposing settlement expansions and elevating diplomatic engagement.

Original Transcript
Sir John Hayes
in the Chair
14:41

Order. I remind Members that they need to bob in order to be called—although, by the look of it, they do not need reminding.

Sir John Hayes
in the Chair

I see a lot of Members are standing. I will not impose a formal time limit, but if people stick to about three minutes, everyone will get in. I discourage interventions.

Sir John Hayes
in the Chair
14:56

I thank Members for their abbreviated remarks. If people keep going in that way, everyone will get in.

Sir John Hayes
in the Chair

I appreciate that the debate is arousing strong feelings, and I want to get everyone in. Please work with me. If Members speak for a couple of minutes each, we will get you all in.

Melanie Ward
Cowdenbeath and Kirkcaldy
Lab
15:13

I thank my hon. Friend for speaking so passionately about her visit.

I worked as a human rights observer in Hebron several years ago, and one thing that is too little understood in this place and the other place is the day-to-day humiliation and degradation that Palestinians are put through, in addition to the horrific violence. Does my hon.

Friend agree that that day-to-day humiliation and degradation are just as unacceptable?

Martin Vickers
Brigg and Immingham
Con

Unlike other Members who have been reflecting on recent visits to the region, although I have visited the region more recently, I visited both Gaza and Israel as long ago as 2012. My reflection when I returned, particularly from Gaza, was how appalling the conditions were.

How much worse they are now. I wrote an article for my church magazine reflecting on my visit to Israel and I said that one could feel the tensions within society. It was not a society at ease with itself, and I suspect that is probably still the case.

In preparing for this contribution, I looked back on the Backbench debate that took place in October 2014 about the recognition of Palestine. I noted that 39 Conservatives voted for recognition, including me and the Father of the House, the right hon. Member for Gainsborough (Sir Edward Leigh).

The right hon. Member for Islington North (Jeremy Corbyn) was a Teller on that occasion, I noted. It would be interesting to hear from the Front Benchers what their views are now on that particular situation.

One of the contributions came from our former colleague Sir Malcolm Rifkind, who of course in the 1990s was Foreign Secretary. His view was that it was not the right time for recognition at that point because to be a recognisable state there needed to be a functioning Government and military.

In the present circumstances, achieving a functioning, democratically accountable Government and all the extensions of that such as a military is clearly an impossibility. I am very interested to hear the Front Benchers’ comments on that.

As the Father of the House said, and I agree entirely, Israel has a perfect right to exist. I would describe myself as a friend of Israel, but friends can be critical and there is a lot to criticise the state of Israel about.

It must surely recognise that its actions in Gaza—while with the perfectly legitimate aim of eliminating Hamas, particularly after the appalling atrocities of 7 October—are creating the Hamas of the future.

They are radicalising the children and young people, who see death and destruction all around. How will they not grow up wanting revenge for what they see? In so many ways, Israel is an admirable country. The people have shown courage.

Their science and technology are very advanced, and the resulting benefits are tremendous. However, Israel has a proportional representation system of Government, which inevitably means coalitions, and the extreme elements that exist within those coalitions will always hold them back.

I very much hope that after this debate a united approach can be taken, whereby we recognise the rights of Israel but are also extremely critical where appropriate.

Sir John Hayes
in the Chair

I will delay calling the Front Benchers until 3.30 pm, so that I can get more Back Benchers in.

Iqbal Mohamed
Dewsbury and Batley
Ind
15:30

It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Sir John. I congratulate the Father of the House, the right hon. Member for Gainsborough (Sir Edward Leigh), on bringing this important debate.

I will cut down my speech to the bare bones and focus on the rights of the Palestinians as attributed to them by the Government here. I believe that the UK’s denial of Palestinian rights for more than a century has directly led to the situation we face today. What rights have we denied them?

As right hon. and hon. Members have mentioned, they have a right for the UK not to refuse to recognise their state, their homeland. They have a right not to be starved and denied essential life supplies, such as water and medicines.

They have a right not to be unlawfully killed by Israeli forces and settlers at any point in their daily lives. They have a right not to be unlawfully and violently evicted from their homes, and forcibly displaced. They have a right not to face abusive detention and torture in Israeli prisons.

They have a right not to face movement restrictions, blockades and checkpoints that prevent pregnant mothers reaching hospitals to deliver babies. They have a right not to face discriminatory laws passed daily by the Israeli Knesset.

They have a right not to undergo collective punishment and not to be sexually abused trying to live their lives.

To conclude, it is clear that successive UK Governments and many in this House have denied the rights of Palestinians, and continue to do so in blind loyalty in defence of Israel and its many war crimes.

Palestinians are as human as any Israeli or Ukrainian, and deserve the same rights from the UK.

Sir John Hayes
in the Chair
15:32

The shadow Minister and the Liberal Democrat spokesman have agreed to have slightly shorter times. I will try to get two more people in for one minute each.

Sir John Hayes
in the Chair

I will enforce a one-minute time limit.

Sir John Hayes
in the Chair

I call Harpreet Uppal. A paragraph, please, Harpreet—no more.

Harpreet Uppal
Huddersfield
Lab
15:38

It is an honour to serve under your chairmanship, Sir John. I thank the Father of the House for bringing forward this vital debate.

The already strained Palestinian healthcare system in the west bank has been further weakened, and is facing significant budget constraints stemming from Israel’s increased withholding of tax revenues meant for the Occupied Palestinian Territories, which it collects on behalf of the Palestinian Authority, as stipulated by the Oslo accords.

The World Health Organisation reports that 45% of essential medications are out of stock, and health workers have not received their full salary for over a year, meaning that most clinics and hospitals are running at significantly reduced levels.

Of course, the effective ban of the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East is impacting the Occupied Palestinian Territories. Hardly any healthcare facilities are running in Gaza. I will leave it there, Sir John.

I am sure that the Minister has heard those concerns.

Sir John Hayes
in the Chair

That was wonderful. A few commas, a couple of semi-colons, but a paragraph, I reckon—don’t you? I call the Liberal Democrat spokesperson.

Sir John Hayes
in the Chair
15:44

Please divide the remaining time by two, allowing Sir Edward a few moments to sum up the debate at the end. I call the shadow Minister.

Sir Edward Leigh
Gainsborough
Con
15:59

Thank you, everybody, for taking part in what has been a very powerful debate. We are completely united. We condemn Hamas, but we stick up unequivocally for the rights of the Palestinian people. Everybody, from all parties or from no party, has made that point—it has even united the right hon.

Member for Islington North (Jeremy Corbyn) and me. Question put and agreed to. Resolved, That this House has considered Government support for Palestinian rights.

All content derived from official parliamentary records