05 Dec 2024
Question
National Resilience
  1. ANALYSIS\n-----------\n\nMain Content and Structure:\n- The focus is on national resilience, with questions posed regarding the steps and progress in strengthening national resilience. The discussion revolves around the integration of external expertise and ensuring resilience is broadly comprehensive, not selective.\n\nPolicy Terms and Key Concepts:\n- National Resilience\n- Resilience Sub-Committee\n- National Security Council\n- Covid Inquiry Module 1\n\nNamed Entities and Participants:\n- Richard Foord, Liberal Democrats, Honiton and Sidmouth\n- Ashley Dalton, Labour, West Lancashire\n- Pat McFadden, Labour, Wolverhampton South East\n- Ms Oppong-Asare, Labour, Erith and Thamesmead (Parliamentary Secretary, Cabinet Office)\n\nReferences and Timeframes:\n- Covid Inquiry Module 1 report recommendations\n- July's announcement of a resilience review\n- Anticipated response to the covid inquiry report within a six-month framework\n- Sweden's crisis preparation initiative as a comparative benchmark\n\nDepartments and Governmental Bodies:\n- Cabinet Office\n- National Security Council\n\nKey Dates:\n- July (announcement of the resilience review)\n- Upcoming month for Government's response\n\nPolitical Positions and Stances:\n- Emphasis on holistic national resilience\n- Inclusions of civil and governmental sectors\n- Past incidents (Covid-19, Grenfell Tower) as reference points for policy formulation\n\n2. SPEAKER POINTS\n----------------\n\nPat McFadden (Labour, Wolverhampton South East):\n- Role: Cabinet Secretary leading the resilience review\n- Arguments and Key Statements:\n - Asserts that national safety is primordial and resilience is a high priority.\n - Discusses integration and consultation across sectors for a broad-based resilience approach.\n- Keywords and Terminology:\n - Groupthink, Resilience, External Expertise\n- Position: Advocates for comprehensive public safety with special attention to vulnerable populations.\n- Questions: Addresses integration of external expertise and methods to combat groupthink.\n\nRichard Foord (Liberal Democrats, Honiton and Sidmouth):\n- Role: Question poseur focused on urging for tangible resilience measures\n- Arguments and Key Statements:\n - Advocates for inclusion of external expertise to strengthen resilience policies.\n - Suggests public awareness initiatives similar to Sweden's to prepare citizens for crises.\n- Keywords and Terminology:\n - Brochure, External Expertise, Groupthink\n- Position: Pushes for proactive dissemination of crisis preparedness information to the general public.\n\nAshley Dalton (Labour, West Lancashire):\n- Role: Inquirer regarding societal impacts of resilience policies\n- Arguments and Key Statements:\n - Highlights the disparate impact of crises on vulnerable groups due to systemic inequities.\n - Pushes for inclusive resilience strategies that cover all societal strata.\n- Keywords and Terminology:\n - Vulnerable, Inclusivity, Resilience for all\n- Position: Emphasizes universal applicability of resilience efforts to ensure protection for all societal segments.\n\nMs Oppong-Asare (Labour, Erith and Thamesmead):\n- Role: Parliamentary Secretary, Cabinet Office mentioned in policy consultations\n- Arguments and Key Statements:\n - Brings to fore the Cabinet's engagement with external experts, highlighting a multi-sectoral consultation approach.\n- Keywords and Terminology:\n - Consultation, External Expertise, Whitehall\n\nCross-references:\n- This discussion synchronizes with broader debates on public safety, Covid-19 impact assessments, and emerging protocols in resilience policy-making.\n- Aligns with prior government inquiries and safety frameworks, learning from past incidences as benchmarks for future resilience measures.\n

Key Contributions

Original Transcript
Richard Foord
Honiton and Sidmouth
LD
Question
UIN: 901637

7. What steps he is taking to increase national resilience.

Ashley Dalton
West Lancashire
Lab
Question
UIN: 901646

13. What recent progress his Department has made on strengthening national resilience.

The Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster
Pat McFadden

The Government’s first responsibility is to keep the public safe, which is why national resilience is a top priority for us. In July, I announced that I would lead a review of resilience, and work has been progressing across Government.

We have engaged at all levels with the public, private and voluntary sectors, and this work is overseen by the dedicated resilience sub-committee of the National Security Council, which I chair.

It is also closely linked to our consideration of the covid inquiry module 1 report, to which the Government will respond next month—within the six-month timeframe set out by the chair of the inquiry.

Richard Foord
10:00

The module 1 report recommended resilience and preparedness, and particularly “Bringing in external expertise from outside government and the Civil Service to…guard against ‘groupthink’”. How is the Minister planning to bring in that external expertise?

Would he consider issuing a brochure to British citizens on preparation for crises, as the Swedish Government have just done?

Pat McFadden
10:00

The hon. Member raises an important point. The Parliamentary Secretary, Cabinet Office, my hon.

Friend the Member for Erith and Thamesmead (Ms Oppong-Asare), has done a great deal of work on consulting people outside Government—external experts across business, the voluntary sector, local government and so on.

It is really important that, as part of this, we hear voices not just from Whitehall but from beyond, too.

Ashley Dalton
10:01

The module 1 report of the UK covid-19 inquiry has found that the impact was most acutely felt by the most vulnerable—the elderly, those with pre-existing health conditions, people living in overcrowded housing, and those on low incomes.

As the Government undertake their review, can the Minister assure the House that they will work to deliver resilience for everyone, not just some of us?

All content derived from official parliamentary records