13 Feb
Question
Topical Questions

Today's question session in the House of Commons tackled an array of issues mostly focused on transportation infrastructure and policies across the UK. The dialogue began with Johanna Baxter from the Labour party prompting a statement about departmental responsibilities. In response, Heidi Alexander unveiled a robust series of government projects, emphasizing investments and upgrades in transport infrastructures, notably a £90 million investment to upgrade major road projects and a £300 million push to promote walking and cycling.

Engagement between speakers highlighted significant regional transport concerns. Johanna Baxter brought attention to potential Scottish metro projects, urging collaboration between the UK and Scottish governments.

£90 million

Investment in major road project upgrades.

A key issue raised was about Heathrow Airport's financial pressure resulting from changes to business rates, with concerns about the cost implications on airport expansion. Heidi Alexander, while filling in responses, focused on the balance of economic growth and environmental obligations.

£300 million

Investment to boost walking and cycling infrastructure.

The session was underscored by specific local issues, including the call for better rail services, road maintenance, and propositions for new transport infrastructures in various regions, demonstrating the parliament's collective aim to strengthen connectivity and efficiency nationwide. Notably, recurring concerns about poor commuter services, lack of disabled access in transit systems, and congestion were tabled.

The dialogue concluded with freight and rail transport topics, once again spotlighting regional transport improvements and future strategies.

£205 million

Funding towards the West Midlands Metro expansion.

Sales increase by 40%

Increase in electric car sales compared to the previous year's January sales.

£124 million

Heathrow Airport's annual business rates contribution.

Outcome

The session yielded reinforced commitments by government ministers towards substantial investments across transport infrastructures. Heidi Alexander's Ministerial team recognized multiple local issues, promised reviews, and agreed on meetings to further push various transit improvement agendas. While the discussion saw disparity in viewpoints, it underscored a necessity for collaborative work across parties to accomplish these infrastructure goals. There were, however, no new concrete proposals outlined during this session.

Key Contributions

Johanna Baxter
Labour

Pressed for a statement on department responsibilities, emphasizing regional transport investments and engagement with Scottish developments.

Heidi Alexander

Outlined significant investment plans improving transport infrastructure across the UK, balancing economic and environmental goals.

Gareth Bacon
Conservative

Highlighted concerns about Heathrow Airport business rate increases impacting expansion.

Mike Kane

Referenced the airports national policy statement regarding private sector funding for surface access issues related to airport expansion.

John Whitby
Labour

Advocated for the construction of a relief road for Ashbourne due to heavy vehicle congestion and pollution.

Lilian Greenwood

Recognized the need for better local transport systems, encouraging ongoing communication with regional authorities.

Mr Paul Kohler
Liberal Democrats

Questioned the current stance of the Secretary of State on a third Heathrow runway, drawing on past views during her Deputy Mayor tenure.

Jessica Toale
Labour

Raised issues from residents regarding constant roadworks affecting daily commuting, sought improvement measures.

Charlie Dewhirst
Conservative

Queried the intended restrictions on open access operators affecting growth and expansion.

Linsey Farnsworth
Labour

Cited reports about poor road conditions in Derbyshire, called for Conservative-led council to utilize the provided funds to improve these conditions.

Jonathan Brash
Labour

Highlighted underperformance in Northern Rail services, requesting ministerial intervention to resolve service issues.

Bob Blackman
Conservative

Sought assurance for comprehensive impact assessments before any Heathrow expansion proposal approval.

Steve Race
Labour

Urged for a strategic transport investment plan to support South-west Peninsula's economy and development.

Cameron Thomas
Liberal Democrats

Voiced concerns over slow and unreliable rail services affecting Gloucestershire’s significant tech and engineering sectors, seeking attention on regional transport links.

Ruth Cadbury
Labour

Questioned whether Heathrow expansion would disproportionately benefit West London, potentially displacing regional jobs.

Martin Vickers
Conservative

Raised concerns about infrequent Northern Rail services in Gainsborough area, advocated for better service provision.

Alison Taylor
Labour

Underscored the necessity of investing in Glasgow’s transport infrastructure to boost economic growth.

David Mundell
Conservative

Addressed frequent flight cancelations affecting Scotland-London connectivity, pushed for collaborative solutions with airlines and authorities.

Rachael Maskell
Labour

Demanded assurance on incorporating disabled access in planning permissions to prevent exclusion in transport infrastructure projects.

Will Forster
Liberal Democrats

Pointed out lack of direct rail link to Heathrow for constituents nearby, advocated for consideration of a submitted improvement business case.

Luke Murphy
Labour

Highlighted backlog in driving tests availability impacting economic activity, urged for expansion of test center capacity and operations.

Tom Gordon
Liberal Democrats

Inquired about promised funds for transport projects in the north post-High Speed 2 cancellation, questioning government's follow-through on regional investment promises.

Josh Dean
Labour

Raised repeated delays in lift installation at a local train station, affecting disabled constituents, urged for a meeting to discuss project acceleration.

Jim Dickson
Labour

Critically addressed economic growth policies concerning lobbying and corporate influence between government and private sectors.

Laurence Turner
Labour

Called for rail infrastructure upgrades to support cross-city line services and local growth potential.

Josh Fenton-Glynn
Labour

Reported inadequate investment in Calder Valley rail improvements for electrification, demanding governmental commitment to these projects.

Sam Rushworth
Labour

Extended invitation to attend bicentennial rail celebrations and discuss governmental involvement in historical railway expansion and tourism.

Original Transcript
Johanna Baxter
Paisley and Renfrewshire South
Lab
10:17
Question
UIN: 902750

T1. If she will make a statement on her departmental responsibilities.

The Secretary of State for Transport
Heidi Alexander
10:18

We are getting on with delivering this Government’s plan for change. Last week I approved upgrades to four major road projects across Wiltshire, Leeds, Essex and Buckinghamshire. That £90 million investment will reduce journey times, ease congestion and improve safety.

It is on the back of drivers’ switching to electric cars in record-breaking numbers, with sales in January more than 40% higher than those last year and nearly 20,000 public charge points added in 2024 alone.

We are backing, with a £205 million investment, the west midlands metro extension, which will take trams from Wednesbury to Brierley Hill.

We are cutting journey times and improving connections for towns with poor public transport links, and yesterday we announced a £300 million investment to get Britain walking and cycling, with hundreds of new footpaths and cycle lanes.

We are delivering the basics of a better transport system, which means improving the everyday journeys that drive economic growth and make people’s lives better.

Johanna Baxter

I met key Scottish stakeholders recently to discuss proposals to bring to the Glasgow city region a metro scheme interconnecting more and more parts of our region, including the towns and villages in my constituency.

Does the Secretary of State agree that it is vital for the Scottish Government to show the same ambition for growth in Scotland as the UK Government have shown in their recent transport announcements, and will she work with the Scottish Government to ensure that this project maximises investment and opportunity for my constituents?

Heidi Alexander

I will always work closely with colleagues in the Scottish Government to ensure that this Government’s ambitions for transport reach all corners of the UK.

The Scottish Government have had a record settlement through the Budget, so I look forward to hearing more about plans for a greater Glasgow metro scheme as they develop.

Mr Speaker
00:00

I call the shadow Secretary of State.

The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Transport
Mike Kane
00:00

This was a policy cooked up by the Valuation Office Agency under His Majesty’s Revenue and Customs by the last Government. We have engaged with airports on this matter and asked them to continue to engage with the Valuation Office Agency.

Gareth Bacon
00:00

I notice that the Minister did not answer my question, so I will assist him. The estimate is that Heathrow’s rates bill will increase fivefold to £600 million annually, putting substantial additional pressure on Heathrow’s finances.

In the light of that, will the Minister confirm the long-standing policy that the full cost of a third runway, including related works such as relocating, tunnelling or bridging over the M25, will be fully funded by the private sector and not by the taxpayer?

Mike Kane

The airports national policy statement from 2018, which was two Governments ago, made it clear that any proposal—we have not had a proposal come forward—should treat surface access appropriately, and that should be funded by the private sector where possible.

John Whitby
Derbyshire Dales
Lab
Question
UIN: 902752

T3. Residents in Ashbourne have been left feeling hopeless and frustrated after waiting decades for a relief road. More than 700 heavy goods vehicles pass through the town each day, endangering local pedestrians, increasing pollution and causing significant congestion.

Will the Minister meet me regarding the need to install a relief road for Ashbourne?

The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Transport
Lilian Greenwood

As my hon. Friend knows, delivering a transport system that meets local, regional and national needs will play a vital role in delivering the missions of this Government.

I encourage him to continue to work with Derbyshire county council, which will hopefully be under new leadership in May, and with our excellent East Midlands Mayor, Claire Ward, to advocate for his constituents’ priorities. I would, of course, be happy to meet him to discuss this.

Mr Speaker
00:00

I call the Liberal Democrat spokesperson.

Mr Paul Kohler
Wimbledon
LD

In her previous role as deputy London Mayor for transport, the Secretary of State stated she was “clear” in her opposition to a third runway at Heathrow. Is she still clear in her opposition, and if not, what has changed her mind?

Heidi Alexander

When I was deputy Mayor for transport in London, I was speaking in that capacity at that time, reflecting the views of the Mayor of London and City Hall on a previous Heathrow expansion scheme.

As Secretary of State, I will consider any airport expansion proposals on their merits and in line with existing processes.

Balancing economic growth and our environmental obligations is central to all my work in this role, and I will always act in the national interest, doing what is right for the country as a whole.

Jessica Toale
Bournemouth West
Lab
Question
UIN: 902756

T6. At least nine major roads in my constituency will be affected by roadworks in the next week. Seemingly endless utility works and roadworks are a crucial issue for my constituents, who have told me it makes them late for work, school pick-up and even hospital appointments.

Can the Minister tell me what steps her Department is taking to improve the situation for my constituents?

Lilian Greenwood

This Government stand with local road users who are frustrated by roadworks that cause unnecessary disruption.

While councils and utility companies should always work together to minimise the impact of their works, we are also taking action: we are doubling fixed penalty notices for utility companies that do not comply with certain requirements for carrying out their street works, and we have extended overrun charges of up to £10,000 per day to weekends and bank holidays, to prevent overrunning roadworks.

Charlie Dewhirst
Bridlington and The Wolds
Con
Question
UIN: 902753

T4.   Open access operators such as Hull Trains offer excellent, cheap, unsubsidised inter-city services to locations across the north, so why are Ministers trying to block their expansion and stifle growth?

Heidi Alexander

There is a balance to be struck here. I welcome services such as those that run to Hull; they open up new routes and new connectivity.

I have, however, asked the Office of Rail and Road to consider the balance in the revenue that they abstract from public operators, and to ensure that we are using constrained capacity in our network appropriately to deliver excellent services for passengers.

Linsey Farnsworth
Amber Valley
Lab
Question
UIN: 902758

T8. The RAC recently reported that potholes in Derbyshire are the worst in the country, but rather than welcoming over £75 million of funding for the east midlands, the Conservatives at Derbyshire county council claim that this is not new money and that it is bound up in red tape.

Does the Minister agree that these are just more excuses, and that the Conservative-controlled Derbyshire county council should stop complaining and start fixing our roads?

Lilian Greenwood

My hon. Friend is absolutely right. The state of our roads is a daily reminder of Tory failure, which is why this Government have provided record funding to fix them. Derbyshire is getting its share of the extra £20 million going to the East Midlands combined authority.

We expect the council to get on with the job and to tell local residents how it intends to use the extra taxpayers’ money that it is getting.

Mr Speaker

I call Dave Doogan—not here.

Mr Jonathan Brash
Hartlepool
Lab

My constituent Kevin Stephenson and many other people in Hartlepool have complained about the shocking underperformance of Northern Rail. He has witnessed passengers being asked to wait in toilets in order to allow more people on to trains.

Services are frequently cancelled, promises of additional carriages have not materialised, and residents are regularly left stranded at stations. Will the Minister work with me to fix the unacceptable level of service?

The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Transport
Simon Lightwood

Ministers and officials are in regular contact with Northern Rail. We recognise that its performance is totally unacceptable, and with the challenges that Northern Rail faces, it will take time to become a stable and reliable service. I would be absolutely delighted to work with my hon. Friend.

Bob Blackman
Harrow East
Con
Question
UIN: 902757

T7. As you will know, Mr Speaker, I rarely, if ever, agree with the Mayor of London, Sadiq Khan.

The Secretary of State has set out the position in relation to her change of heart, but will she commit to ensure that any proposal for a third runway at Heathrow will have a full impact assessment before it is approved or denied?

Heidi Alexander

I fully support the Chancellor’s call for fresh proposals for Heathrow. Some of our airports in the south-east are running at or near capacity. We cannot pretend that that is not the case, and I am not prepared to be part of a Government who duck the difficult decisions.

As the person who may ultimately be taking planning decisions on any application for a third runway at Heathrow, I will judge any scheme on its merits. We will update the airports national policy statement, and any expansion scheme must meet our legal and environmental obligations.

Steve Race
Exeter
Lab

As the Secretary of State knows, the south-west peninsula already contributes significantly to the UK economy, including through life sciences and climate tech.

We are, however, held back from reaching our full potential by under-investment in transport connectivity, which is made worse by upcoming works at Old Oak Common and the continuing bottleneck on the A303.

Will the Minister commit to developing a strategic investment plan to ensure that the south-west peninsula has the transport infrastructure it needs to unlock further growth?

Simon Lightwood

As I have said before, growth is the priority mission of this Government, and we are committed to empowering local leaders. A regional transport strategy, and a strategic investment plan for the south-west, has been developed by the sub-national transport body Peninsula Transport.

Cameron Thomas
Tewkesbury
LD

As well as being home to both GCHQ and NATO’s Allied Rapid Reaction Corps headquarters, Gloucestershire has the largest concentration of cyber-tech businesses and aerospace engineering firms outside London, but the county, and particularly Tewkesbury, is subject to slow, unreliable and grossly outdated rail services.

It is also underserved by road transport links eastward.

Mr Speaker

Order. We are on topicals—I think you need an Adjournment debate. Who is going to answer that?

Simon Lightwood

I will certainly meet the hon. Gentleman to discuss this matter.

Mr Speaker

I call the Chair of the Transport Committee.

Ruth Cadbury
Brentford and Isleworth
Lab

Department for Transport analysis carried out in 2017 showed that expanding Heathrow would displace 27,000 jobs from the UK regions to London by 2050, with 17 million fewer passengers using non-London airports.

Does the Minister hope that the same analysis, if done now, would come to a different conclusion in order to ensure that UK economic growth really does benefit all UK regions and not just west London?

Mike Kane
10:29

The Government are committed to regional airports. I am proudly wearing my “Yes to R2” badge from when we built a second runway at Manchester airport in 2001. The position is quite the opposite of what my hon.

Friend describes: under the 2018 airports national policy statement, the number of connections from Heathrow to regional airports was expected to increase if Heathrow expanded, increasing productivity in those regions.

Martin Vickers
Brigg and Immingham
Con
10:30

Northern Trains runs one train per day on the Gainsborough-Brigg-Cleethorpes line. Does the Secretary of State agree that one train per day is pretty pointless?

Will she arrange a meeting with the appropriate Minister for me and other affected MPs, so that we can discuss how to secure a better service?

Heidi Alexander
10:30

Reliable, frequent train services are important, no matter where in the country we live. I will ask the Rail Minister for a meeting.

Alison Taylor
Paisley and Renfrewshire North
Lab
10:31

Does the Minister agree that achieving economic growth requires sustained investment in our transport infra- structure?

Would she be willing to visit Glasgow International airport to learn more about how transport infrastructure can assist with the further development of the proposed investment zone in my constituency?

Simon Lightwood
10:31

I agree that investment in our transport infrastructure across the country is essential to our growth mission. I am aware of the investment zone bid involving Glasgow airport, and the aviation Minister, my hon.

Friend the Member for Wythenshawe and Sale East (Mike Kane), would be delighted to visit in the near future.

David Mundell
Dumfriesshire, Clydesdale and Tweeddale
Con
10:30

I do not know whether the Secretary of State is aware that large swathes of British Airways flights between London and Scotland are automatically cancelled when there are serious weather or technical issues at Heathrow.

British Airways says that if the Secretary of State’s officials, the Civil Aviation Authority, Heathrow and airlines worked together, the number of cancellations could be minimised, even in those circumstances, so will she facilitate those discussions?

Mike Kane
10:32

The right hon. Member raises an important point. The resilience of the UK aviation sector is important, and key to its success, so we will facilitate any discussions to make sure we are always on an improvement trajectory.

Simon Lightwood
10:32

The accessibility of all modes of transport is extremely important to this Government. I would be delighted to meet my hon. Friend to discuss this matter further.

Mr Will Forster
Woking
LD
10:33

Despite my constituency being only a stone’s throw from Heathrow, we have no direct rail link to the country’s busiest airport. Last week, Heathrow Southern Railway submitted a business case to the Government.

When will the Government consider it, to ensure that my constituents can get a train to Heathrow?

Heidi Alexander
10:33

Alongside the question of how many planes should take off and land at Heathrow, there is the critical question of how people get to the airport. The hon. Gentleman makes an important point, and I would be happy to discuss it further with him.

Luke Murphy
Basingstoke
Lab
10:33

Learner drivers in Basingstoke have been left stranded for months—in some cases, years—unable to book a driving test. That is affecting their jobs, their education and the local economy.

Does the Secretary of State agree that urgent action is needed to extend test centre hours, to ramp up the recruitment of examiners, and to clamp down on the rip-off companies that book multiple slots, only to flog them at higher prices?

Lilian Greenwood

My hon. Friend is right to raise these concerns on behalf of learner drivers. On 18 December, the Driver and Vehicle Standards Agency set out a seven-point plan that recognises the need to fix the driving test booking system, so that we can get new drivers on the road.

I will hold it to account for delivery of that plan and the changes that my hon. Friend and his constituents need to see.

Tom Gordon
Harrogate and Knaresborough
LD
10:34

When the previous Government cancelled High Speed 2, they promised more than £4 billion for projects in the north and the midlands. Do the Government still plan to deliver on that, and when should we expect to see that money in the north?

Heidi Alexander
10:34

I hate to tell the hon. Gentleman this, but that was fantasy money. We are working through a pipeline of transport infrastructure projects, and will make announcements alongside the spending review.

Josh Dean
Hertford and Stortford
Lab
10:34

The long-promised platform 1 lift at Hertford North station, due to be delivered under the Access for All scheme, has been delayed yet again. This leaves some of my disabled constituents having to travel back up the line to get a different train to platform 2, so that they can use the lift there.

Will the appropriate Minister meet me to discuss how we can urgently drive forward the lift project for my constituents?

Lilian Greenwood
10:35

My hon. Friend is absolutely right to raise concerns about disabled access at his local station. We want to ensure that everyone can access our public transport networks, and I would be happy to ensure that I or one of my colleagues met him.

Jim Dickson
Dartford
Lab
10:35

On economic growth, which we have discussed, will the Secretary of State clarify, for the benefit of the Conservative party, that economic growth depends on rather more than a well-oiled revolving door between the Tory party and big business—a door through which a former Tory Transport Minister and Member of the other place unsuccessfully attempted to walk last week?

Heidi Alexander
10:35

Delivering economic growth requires a proper plan for investment in our transport infrastructure. That is exactly what this Government are determined to deliver.

Laurence Turner
Birmingham Northfield
Lab
10:36

Once Birmingham’s Camp Hill line reopens, we will need track investment if we are to restore the pre-pandemic service frequencies on the cross-city line, including to Northfield and Longbridge. Will the Minister look fully at the case for upgrading King’s Norton station?

Josh Fenton-Glynn
Calder Valley
Lab

The Calder Valley line was listed as a top priority for improvements by Transport for the North’s electrification taskforce 10 years ago, back in 2015, yet my constituents are still waiting for those improvements.

Will the Minister commit this Government to delivering the infrastructure for my constituents that the last Government could not?

Heidi Alexander
10:37

Network Rail is completing a strategic outline business case, covering electrification of the Calder Valley line. The business case will be considered in the context of the wider electrification strategy, so that we can determine how to deliver the best possible benefits across the region.

Sam Rushworth
Bishop Auckland
Lab
10:37

Next month, railway enthusiasts from around the world will come to my constituency, where we will mark the 200th anniversary of the Stockton and Darlington railway, which took off from the town of Shildon. Will my right hon.

Friend ask the Rail Minister to meet me and other MPs along that route to talk about how the Government can be part of those celebrations?

Heidi Alexander

I am sure that is an invitation that the Rail Minister could not possibly refuse.

Mr Speaker

On that basis, I look forward to a Minister opening the Coppull railway station, or at least doing an impact study on the main line.

All content derived from official parliamentary records