12 Mar
Department Question
Wales

The Department Question session on Wales in the UK Parliament was largely centered on crucial issues such as the impact of rising national insurance contributions and the support schemes for employment, businesses, the Crown Estate, agriculture, NHS, education, and the tourism sector. Discussions highlighted tensions between the Labour and Conservative parties, alongside contributions from Plaid Cymru, Liberal Democrats, and SNP representatives.

  1. Employment and National Insurance:
    • Jo Stevens outlined measures taken to protect small businesses in Wales, including expanding the employment allowance.
    • Mims Davies criticized the national insurance rise for threatening Welsh jobs and questioned the investments in foreign campuses like that of Cardiff University.
  1. Crown Estate and Renewable Energy:
    • Discussion on devolving the Crown Estate emphasized the potential economic gains through offshore wind energy projects in the Celtic Sea, potentially creating over 5,000 jobs.
    • Debates about managing the Crown Estate's revenues were highlighted, with contrasts between the interests of the Scottish and Welsh Governments.
99.3%

Small and medium-sized companies' share in total enterprises in Wales.

  1. Agricultural Relief and Business:
    • Dame Nia Griffith confirmed minimal impact from changes to Property Reliefs on Welsh farms and emphasized protecting farming budgets.
  1. Healthcare and NHS:
    • Clive Jones pointed to struggles in meeting cancer treatment targets, while Dame Nia Griffith noted improvements in waiting lists and healthy investments in healthcare services.
£10,500

Current employment allowance limit for small businesses.

  1. Tourism and Economic Support:
    • The effectiveness of proposed measures like the visitor levy were debated, with Jo Stevens highlighting planned investments in Welsh cultural venues.
    • Mims Davies criticized the tax policy as injurious to tourism-related businesses.
  1. Education and Budget Investments:
    • Discussions touched on educational standards, with the Welsh Government investing significant funds in school standards and literacy programs, despite opposition votes from Plaid Cymru and Conservatives.

The debate revealed deep divisions in policy approaches, questioning the efficacy of implemented and proposed governmental measures based on party lines.

5,300

Number of jobs forecasted from offshore wind projects in the Celtic sea.

£337 million

Farming budget protected for Wales.

26 years

Duration of Labour governance in Wales.

Outcome

The session underscored a tangible disparity in recognizing priorities between financial burdens on businesses and enhancements in public sectors like education and health. Ongoing disagreements regarding devolved powers and budget allocations were prevalent, with little resolution achieved but major points outlined for future debates.

Key Contributions

Rebecca Smith
Conservative

Expressed concern over the impact of national insurance rises on Welsh businesses, parallel to her South West Devon constituency.

Jo Stevens

Defended the government's measures for small businesses.

Mims Davies
Conservative

Criticized national insurance hike as risky to Welsh jobs.

David Chadwick
Liberal Democrats

Questioned criteria of government funding allocation for Welsh high streets.

Liz Saville Roberts
PC (Plaid Cymru)

Highlighted potential staff layoffs due to national insurance changes.

Stephen Gethins
SNP (Scottish National Party)

Queried discussions on devolving the Crown Estate.

Tonia Antoniazzi
Labour

Supported job creation through the Crown Estate rather than focusing on devolution debates.

John Cooper
Conservative

Expressed concern about changes in agricultural property relief affecting farmers.

Dame Nia Griffith

Discussed minimal impact from agricultural relief changes and safeguarded farming budgets.

Clive Jones
Liberal Democrats

Questioned effectiveness of Welsh Government's cancer strategies amid past missed targets.

Joe Robertson
Conservative

Urged for reduction in tax burdens to drive tourism sector.

Henry Tufnell
Labour

Encouraged sustainable tourist levies to foster local economies.

Douglas McAllister
Labour

Criticized nationalist opposition to budgetary provisions for NHS improvements.

Jim Shannon
DUP

Advocated for unified UK strategy on diabetes management.

Graham Leadbitter
SNP (Scottish National Party)

Skeptically evaluated Union strength relative to budget allocations for major projects like HS2.

Andrew Ranger
Labour

Praised government investment in Welsh regions, promoting local growth.

Sir Ashley Fox
Conservative

Linked low educational performance to prolonged Labour governance in Wales.

Original Transcript

All content derived from official parliamentary records